You can’t choose the appraiser, but you can choose who’s at your side. Choose wisely.
Whenever a bank loan’s involved, you can bet an appraiser is too.
The bank hires them to make sure they’re not loaning a million bucks against something worth $300K. They’re not there to predict whether the buyer will default, just to confirm the collateral makes sense.
When it comes to houses, they usually get it right. Plenty of comps, plenty of data. Every house is technically different, but they can pull enough nearby sales to pin down value pretty well.
Land is a whole different ballgame.
Finding relevant comps is harder, and the results can get screwy fast. I once had two residential lot deals going at the same time, same area, same price point, roughly $120K each. Two different appraisers. One came back right at $120K. The other came in at $75K.
One was close. The other wasn’t.
That buyer kicked in extra cash and closed anyway, but that’s rare. A low appraisal usually blows up the deal for everyone. The appraiser still gets paid the same either way.
Another listing went under contract at full price. Buyer was paying cash but got an appraisal anyway, just to make the partners feel better.
You probably know where this is going.
The appraiser used awful comps. One seven miles away in a rural area, one outdated, and one sitting mostly in floodplain without adjusting for it. The only relevant comp, he adjusted down for no reason anyone could explain. If anything, that comp made us look underpriced.
His report told my buyers they were overpaying by $500K.
They walked.
A few months later, the highway route was announced. That property’s now a future corner. We doubled the price, and we’ll get it.
That appraiser’s “discount” cost those buyers seven figures in future value.
To be fair, most appraisers just don’t have enough experience with land. They’re used to houses. Land’s a different animal.
But you know what wrecks just as many deals? Agents out of their depth.
Most agents focus on houses. Nothing wrong with that, unless they list land without knowing what they’re doing. Overprice it and the property sits forever. Underprice it and you leave money on the table. Miss a key issue and you get expensive surprises later.
We all have the same real estate license. That doesn’t make every agent qualified for every deal.
If you were leasing retail space, would you hire your cousin Karen who’s never read a lease? Even if she asks. And she’ll understand why you don’t.
So why list land with someone who doesn’t specialize in it? She will understand why you don’t there also.
Does it make sense to hire people who aren’t experts in a specialized field?
Does it make sense to fly blind when there’s someone offering a free analysis of your property?
Even if you aren’t considering selling today, does it hurt to know what you might be sitting on?
Ready for me to shut up?
Click below.
Got a lot you might want to sell?
Get a FREE, no obligation report on what it could sell for today.
Get Your Lot Valuation
Own land instead?
Get a report for that here:
Get Your Land Value
Just a glutton for punishment?
Sign up now to get more articles like this in your email.
Sign Up Now









